The first painter who might be called baroque was Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio. Caravaggio, as he was known, worked mostly in Rome. There he painted a number of large canvases that depicted religious subjects from the New Testament. His subject matter remained traditional. But his realistic treatment of the human figure and the setting was radically new. In such paintings as The Calling of St. Matthew (1599-1602), Caravaggio set the story not at the time of Christ but in his own time. The costumes of the figures as well as the architecture and furnishings of the interior setting are based on contemporary Roman fashions. Sometimes the figures in his paintings can be identified as his friends. The only element in Caravaggio's religious paintings that suggests a divine presence is his use of tenebrist light. This is a sharply contrasting spotlighting that resembles stage lighting.
Caravaggio's realistic depiction of biblical stories was very different from the approach taken by his contemporary Annibale Carracci. Carracci's paintings return to the clarity of design and balanced composition of such High Renaissance artists as Raphael. Most of Carracci's paintings were of religious subjects. But his most famous works were the frescoes on the ceiling of the Farnese Gallery in Rome (1597-1605). They illustrate mythological scenes from the writings of the Roman poet Ovid. Many of the figures are based on classical statues or the paintings of Raphael and Michelangelo. They appear lifelike. But they are so idealized they could never be confused with real figures in real settings.
A third approach to art was taken by Pietro da Cortona. He excelled as both an architect and a painter. He painted the large ceiling fresco The Triumph of Divine Providence (1633-39) in the Palazzo Barberini, Rome. It is a dazzling composition of loosely arranged, colorful figures that swirl freely overhead. In style as well as in subject, this is far removed from the realism of Caravaggio or the timelessness of Carracci. Cortona's Triumph is, in fact, a representation of the supernatural. It is an imaginary vision of the ascent to immortality of a living person, Pope Urban VIII Barberini.
One artist who seemed to capture the spirit of his time in all its diversity and vitality was the sculptor Giovanni Lorenzo Bernini. His statue David (1623) was done when he was still a young man. It expresses most of the characteristic features of baroque art. Its pose imitates sculpture from the ancient past. But it is also very realistically rendered. Like many works of art from this period, it represents one moment in a continuous action. In this case it is David hurling a stone from his sling at Goliath. Finally, it draws the spectator into the action. It makes him or her an active participant in the story being told.
Bernini preferred sculpture. But he also designed a number of architectural projects that contribute to the magnificence of Rome. Chief among these was his completion of the rebuilding of St. Peter's Basilica. The basilica is the most important church in the Catholic world. He sculpted a number of works for the interior of the great church. And in the 1650's he designed and built the enormous open square that stands in front of it. This square, or piazza, consists of two curving colonnades that are shaped like arms that reach out to gather in the faithful. This is a symbolic gesture that Bernini noted in writings that accompanied his plans. Walking through St. Peter's Square today, one still experiences the majesty, the authority, and the self-confidence of the baroque popes.