The dyed birds fly around a city square in Italy.
Close Caption
©Tony Gentile/Reuters/Alamy Stock Photo
Painted Pigeons
Is it right for artists to capture and paint live animals in the name of art?

Birds in two European cities have unwittingly become part of an artwork. A pair of artists installed a cage-like device on a rooftop in Copenhagen, Denmark, and later in Venice, Italy. When pigeons fly inside, a conveyor belt carries them through the contraption. It sprays the birds with non-toxic dye that fades over time. The machine then releases the tropical-looking pigeons back into their urban habitats. Some people see the project as a fascinating public artwork. But critics say that trapping and dyeing the birds is a form of animal abuse.

Artists Julius von Bismarck and Julian Charrière, both based in Berlin, Germany, are the team behind the pigeon-painting work. They argue that their device does not harm the pigeons.

People often ignore flocks of pigeons, and the artists hope their brilliantly colored birds will change the way people see and interact with the animals. Many people applaud the artists for creating a new form of street art (visual art in a public location) that uses colorful, living sculptures and entire cities as canvases. The avian-airbrushing apparatus and photographs of the colorful birds were later displayed in a gallery.

This isn’t the first time artists have used animals in their installations. The street artist Banksy painted a live elephant in 2006, for example, which angered animal-rights activists. People thought it was unfair to treat a living creature as an object. They worried that forcing the animal to take part in the artwork caused it stress and was inhumane.

What do you think? Is it ethical to use living creatures in art?

CRAFT AN ARGUMENT
1. What arguments do people make in support of Von Bismarck and Charrière’s artwork?
2. Why do some people consider artworks like this one unethical?
3. Use evidence from the text and your own opinions to explain why animals should or should not be used in artworks.


If the pigment is actually non toxic and the birds are treated with respect and gentle understanding, I'm not opposed to painting them. But how do you know what the birds are feeling. Do they care? If people treat the birds better when they are colorfully painted the birds benefit from the experience. They may be fed more and not chased away. I actually think this is an interesting and creative idea by the artists. I think it would be fun to see these birds in these colors.
Posted by: Maky Z. | April 17, 2017 at 5:47 PM

Post a Comment

Comments are moderated by Scholastic Editors. Your comments will not appear until they are approved by the Editors.
Enter your first name and the first initial of your last name only :
Enter comments here: